Our Mission
Islam VS Ahmadiyya is a research library that compares the beliefs of Orthodox Islam and the Ahmadiyya movement. Every claim is examined honestly using primary sources, careful historical evidence, and critical thinking — so you can weigh the facts and reach your own conclusions.
Featured Articles
Our most impactful and recently published research.
Beyond Monolithic Narratives: A Balanced Look at Orthodox and Ahmadiyya History
Ahmadiyya apologists routinely paint all 1.8 billion orthodox Muslims as violent. Historical records—including the murder of Fakhruddin Multani, the 1974 Rabwah train station incident, and other documented episodes—show that individuals in both groups have instigated violence, and broad generalizations do not reflect the reality of either community.
June 1, 2026 MGA and the British Empire: Loyalty, Anti-Jihad Preaching, and Praise for Queen Victoria
Ahmadi apologetics often reframes Mirza Ghulam Ahmad's praise of British rule as a simple acknowledgment of religious freedom. The primary sources show something much stronger. He repeatedly presented loyalty to the British Empire as a principle of his movement, publicly celebrated Queen Victoria's jubilee, urged Muslims toward obedience to the colonial state, and tied his anti-jihad preaching to his own messianic mission.
May 30, 2026 Only Two Are Binding: The Qur'an, the Sunnah, and the Myth of 'Rejecting Your Own Scholars'
Ahmadis dig up a scholar's isolated opinion or a mystic's stray utterance, then cry 'you reject your own scholars' when Muslims say no. But in Islam only the Qur'an and authentic Sunnah are binding — everything else is weighed, not worshipped.
May 30, 2026 Two Men, Not One: Why the Mahdi and Jesus Are Distinct in Islam
Ahmadis collapse the Mahdi and the descending Jesus into a single person to make room for Mirza Ghulam Ahmad. The authentic hadith corpus — and Mirza's own pen — say otherwise.
May 29, 2026Where to Begin
Four ways into the material, whether you are new to the topic or doing deep research.
Start Here
New to the topic? Get the essential background in a few minutes.
Explore →Articles
Browse the searchable research library, organised by category.
Explore →Resource Library
Original document scans, recommended reading, and a glossary.
Explore →Support
Community, guidance, and a confidential way to reach out.
Explore →Examine the Evidence for Yourself
Read the primary sources, follow the references, and think critically. The goal is not to tell you what to believe, but to give you the facts to decide.